FOD-Detection.com

The Concorde conviction is overturned. The strip still did it.

This site opened a question in February 2010 and did not go back to close it. Here is the answer.

When the trial opened, Continental’s defence was that the fire aboard Concorde began eight seconds before the aircraft reached the titanium strip — that the strip was on the runway, certainly, but that the aeroplane was already burning by the time it got there. Had that held, the founding fact of this entire industry would have been wrong.

On 6 December 2010 the Paris court rejected it. Continental Airlines and John Taylor, the mechanic who fitted the strip in Houston, were convicted of involuntary manslaughter. Continental was fined €200,000 and ordered to pay Air France some €1.08 million. Taylor was fined €2,000 and given a fifteen-month suspended sentence.

On 29 November 2012 the appeal court set both convictions aside. Judge Michèle Luga found that the errors, real as they were, did not amount to criminal responsibility for the deaths of 113 people.

Read the headlines and you would think the strip had been exonerated. It was not. Two things survived the appeal intact.

The first is civil liability: Continental remained civilly responsible, and the award to Air France of a little over a million euros stood. The second, and the one that matters here, is the physical sequence. The appeal court accepted that the wrong metal was fitted, that it fell from the DC-10 onto the runway at Charles de Gaulle, that it burst Concorde’s tyre, and that the tyre debris started the fire. What the court declined to do was convert that chain into a crime.

That distinction is worth holding on to, because this industry exists because of the chain and not the conviction. Every system this site has covered since 2008 rests on the proposition that a piece of metal lying on a runway can destroy an aircraft. An appeal court, having heard twelve years of argument from lawyers paid to break that proposition, did not break it. It ruled on culpability and left the physics where it found it.

There is a smaller lesson, and it is about this site rather than the accident. We published the doubt in February 2010 and did not report the verdict when it came that December. Anyone reading here in the two years since would have found the question opened and left hanging, while every later piece went on citing the strip as settled. It is settled — the appeal court has just said so in the course of acquitting the people who put it there — but we should have said so at the time.

Sources (France 24, Al Jazeera)