FOD-Detection.com

Beta — rebuilt from the original spreadsheet

FOD risk calculator

Assess the reduction in risk from installing a FOD detection system, or compare systems against each other. Risk is measured in FOD minutes — quantity of FOD multiplied by the time it spends on the runway.

Parameters

FOD system
mins

Enter a number of 0 or more.

%

Enter a number from 0 to 100.

Airport
items

Enter a whole number of 0 or more.

mins

Enter a number of 0 or more.

hrs

Enter a number of 0.1 or more.

mins

Enter a number of 0.1 or more.

%

Enter a number from 0 to 100.

92%
Reduction in annual FOD risk

Risk falls from 54,000 to 4,410 FOD minutes a year.

Annual risk, in FOD minutes

No detection system line 9 54,000
With detection system line 12 4,410
Calculated lines 8–12
8Time on runway6 mins
9Risk, no detection system54,000
10Risk from items found manually2,700
11Risk from items found by the system1,710
12Total risk with detection system4,410

Why probability beats speed

The three systems from the original spreadsheet, recalculated against the airport parameters you have entered. System C is the slowest to detect — fourteen minutes against System B's seven — yet it finishes ahead, because it misses nothing.

Total annual risk with each system, in FOD minutes — shorter is better

Methodology

The model measures risk in FOD minutes: the number of debris items that appear on the runway in a year, multiplied by the time each one stays there. It is a measure of exposure, not of damage — one item lying on the surface for an hour and sixty items lying there for a minute each score the same.

Symbols

NFOD items found per year 3
pProbability of detection, as a fraction 2
tdDetection time, minutes 1
trRetrieval time, minutes 4
TmTime between manual checks, hours 5
taTime between aircraft movements, minutes 6
fFraction of FOD originating from aircraft 7

Time on the runway line 8

An item is on the surface from the moment it lands there until it is picked up, so the exposure per item is detection time plus retrieval time:

t= td+tr

If the runway is closed while the debris is retrieved, no aircraft is exposed during the retrieval, and the term drops out: t=td. That is what the checkbox on the form does.

Risk with no detection system line 9

With manual inspection only, an item can arrive at any point in the gap between two checks. Averaged over many items, it waits half that gap. The interval is entered in hours, so it is multiplied by 60:

Rnone= N⁢ 60⁢Tm 2

This is the baseline every result is compared against. Note what it does not contain: detection time, probability of detection, or anything else about a system. Six-hourly checks give every item an average of three hours on the runway whatever else is true.

Risk from items the system misses line 10

A system with probability of detection p misses a fraction 1−p of items. Those are not found until the next manual check, so they carry the full manual exposure:

Rmissed= N⁢ (1−p)⁢ 60⁢Tm 2

A few items, each on the runway for hours. This term is why probability of detection dominates the result: every percentage point missed is charged at the manual rate, which is two or three orders of magnitude worse than the detected rate below.

Risk from items the system finds line 11

Detected items are cleared in t minutes rather than hours. Where that clearance is quicker than the gap between aircraft movements, two further reductions apply, and the term becomes piecewise:

Rfound= { N⁢p⁢t⁢ (1−f)⁢ tta if t<ta N⁢p⁢t otherwise

The factor (1−f) removes debris shed by aircraft: it arrives as a movement happens, so the next aircraft is a full interval away and the item is gone before that aircraft arrives. The factor tta is the chance that a movement falls inside the window the item is actually there for. When clearance takes longer than the gap between movements, neither reduction applies and every item is exposed to traffic for its full dwell — the lower branch.

Total risk with a detection system line 12

Rwith= Rmissed+ Rfound

The headline percentage at the top of this page is simply how much smaller that is than the baseline:

reduction= 1− Rwith Rnone

What the model assumes

Three assumptions are worth stating plainly, because they bound how far the output should be trusted. Items are assumed to arrive uniformly in time, which is why the average wait is half the inspection interval; a runway that receives most of its debris during a morning departure bank does not behave that way. Detection time and probability of detection are treated as single figures, when in reality both vary with object size, material and weather. And the model counts exposure, not consequence: it does not know whether the item is a bolt or a baggage-cart wheel, and makes no attempt to convert FOD minutes into damage, delay or cost.

Its purpose is comparison rather than prediction. Run the same airport parameters against two systems and the ranking is meaningful; treat the absolute number as a forecast of damage and it is not.

Definitions and notes

Line 1
Time taken for an object to appear as "detected" by the system after first appearing on the airfield surface.
Line 2
The probability that the system will detect an object.
Line 3
Total number of actual FOD items found on the airfield surface in 1 year (it includes those found by the FOD detection system and those found during manual checks).
Line 4
The average time it takes to retrieve an object once it has been detected by the FOD detection system. This would typically be larger for larger airports.
Line 5
The average time between manual FOD checks.
Line 6
The average time between aircraft movements on a runway.
Line 7
If 1/2 of all FOD found is from aircraft then this number would be 50%. This number should be known (assuming proper records of FOD finds are kept).
Line 8
The Detection time + Retrieval time. i.e. how long an item is on the runway.
Line 9
The total risk when no FOD detection system is installed.
Line 10
Risk from items not found by the system, but found during manual inspection. (small number of items, but would have been on the runway for a long period i.e hours)
Line 11
The risk from those items that were found by the FOD system (large number of items, but would have been on the runway for a short period i.e minutes)
Line 12
The total risk from FOD when a FOD detection system is installed. This should typically be around a tenth of the risk when no FOD system is installed.

About this rebuild

The original calculator ran as an embedded Microsoft Office spreadsheet. That service was retired and the tool stopped working. This version reimplements the same model directly in the page, with the formulas taken cell-for-cell from the original workbook.

Download the original spreadsheet (.xls) — it compares three systems side by side and shows the working.

With thanks to Kartik Nathan at Microsoft, who helped build the original.

From model to procurement

Using these numbers in an airport business case or tender? See the RFP & buyer’s evaluation checklist for how probability of detection, wet-runway false alarms and retrieval times translate into contract specifications, and the economics of FOD for why the civil and military business cases diverge.