FOD-Detection.com

Bubble wrap on the airfield stalls a 737 engine out of Houston

United flight 1118, a Boeing 737-900 with 167 people aboard, left Houston Intercontinental for Fort Myers on 4 March and got as far as about 12,000ft before the left CFM56 produced a series of bangs and streaks of flame down the side of the aircraft. The crew stopped the climb and returned, landing on runway 27 around 35 minutes after departure. Nobody was hurt, and the passengers went on to Florida that evening on a different aeroplane.

The engine was not on fire. It was a compressor stall, and what the passengers filmed was excess fuel burning off. The airline’s explanation of what caused it is the interesting part: the engine had ingested plastic bubble wrap that was lying on the airfield before departure.

This is the cheap end of FOD and by some distance the most instructive. No titanium strip, no wheel fragment, no ramp equipment — packaging, loose airside, sucked off the surface by an engine at take-off power.

It is also the hardest thing to find. Light non-metallic debris is the worst target class there is for a radar-based detection system: little to reflect, low profile against the pavement, and, unlike a bolt or a bracket, it does not stay put. Bubble wrap moves with the wind and with every jet blast that passes it. The runway inspection that missed it may well have been faultless twenty minutes earlier, when the wrap was somewhere else entirely.

Which is the argument this site keeps making in a different form. Inspection is a snapshot; debris arrives between snapshots, and the mobile, low-signature kind arrives repeatedly. The hybrid radar and electro-optical designs exist precisely because the radar half of the problem cannot see this sort of thing on its own.

167 people, a shut-down engine and a diversion, for a piece of packing material. There is no exotic engineering lesson in it at all, which is rather the point.

Source (KHOU, AeroInside)