FOD-Detection.com

Muan: the state report says the concrete wall was a cost decision

The state report into the Jeju Air 2216 crash at Muan has been published, and it answers the question this site put on the day: why the localiser antenna beyond the end of runway 19 was mounted on reinforced concrete rather than on something built to break.

The answer is money. South Korea’s Board of Audit and Inspection found the structure had been built as it was because the ministry “sought to reduce costs”. The terrain fell away beyond the runway end, the localiser needed elevation to radiate correctly, and levelling the ground would have meant earthworks nobody wanted to pay for. A concrete plinth was cheaper.

The report also concludes that the landing itself was survivable, and that the 179 people who died need not have. In December last year South Korea’s Anti-Corruption and Civil Rights Commission ruled the structure non-compliant; it has since been demolished and replaced with frangible construction.

That is a complete account of a failure, and it is worth setting down plainly because of how ordinary each step in it was. Nobody decided to put a wall at the end of a runway. Somebody decided that a foundation adequate to hold an antenna steady was the economical way to solve a survey problem, and the frangibility requirement — which exists for exactly one scenario, the one that happened — was not the constraint anybody was optimising against. It was then inspected, signed off and reported as compliant for years.

This site covers the objects on the runway that nobody sees. Muan is the other case: the object everybody saw, every day, and had stopped thinking of as an object. Every airfield has some of those, and unlike debris they do not blow away between inspections.

The initiating hazard was still wildlife, and that part of the chain is unchanged. But it is the four metres of concrete that turned a survivable overrun into the worst accident in Korean aviation history, and the report says so without much attempt at softening it.

Source (Malay Mail)