FOD-Detection.com

A torch left in an F-35 engine costs four million dollars

At Luke Air Force Base in Arizona on 15 March 2023, a maintainer left a hand-held torch inside the engine of an F-35A Lightning II during an inspection. The engine was subsequently test-run. The damage came to about four million dollars.

The Air Force accident investigation board report records a maintenance member’s words to the expeditor:

I believe I just ingested a flashlight.

No detection system on this site would have prevented it, and it is worth being explicit about why. Every system this site covers — radar, electro-optical, hybrid, mobile — watches a surface. The debris in this event was never on a surface. It went from a toolbox into an engine without ever touching the pavement.

That is the boundary of the technology, and it is a good deal narrower than the industry’s own cost figures imply. When you see FOD costed at four billion dollars a year in direct damage, or twenty-two billion including consequential costs, a large share of that is tool control, hangar discipline, line maintenance and ramp housekeeping. Runway detection systems address the part of the problem that lies on the runway. They are not a FOD programme, they are one instrument within one.

Which is also why the case for buying one is so hard to make on the raw cost-of-FOD number. An airport that installs a detection system has not bought a share of four billion dollars. It has bought a reduction in the time debris spends on its runway surface, against the traffic using that runway. That is a much smaller number and a much more honest one, and it is the only basis on which these systems have ever been worth buying.

Four million dollars for a torch. The cheapest FOD prevention measure in aviation remains a shadow board and somebody counting the tools back in.

Source (Flying Magazine)