FOD-Detection.com

Moog claims a 75 per cent cut in FOD damage for the US Marine Corps

Moog is reporting that the US Navy and Marine Corps have achieved a 75 per cent reduction in FOD-related aircraft damage through the automated detection, prevention and mitigation approach deployed at Marine Corps Air Station Yuma.

If that number holds up, it is the most significant operational result this technology has ever produced, and it deserves scrutiny rather than applause.

What it would demonstrate is the thing nobody has been able to show in eighteen years of civil deployment: a measured reduction in damage attributable to a detection system, at a real airfield, over a real period. Every civil business case in this field has been built on modelling, because no civil airport has published before-and-after damage data. The FAA’s own cost-benefit analysis had to work from detection counts for exactly this reason.

The caveats are substantial and Moog’s own phrasing contains them. This is a 75 per cent reduction from an “approach” comprising detection, prevention and mitigation — not from a radar. Yuma installed Tarsier in 2020 as part of a programme that also involved procedural change, sweeping regimes and command attention on FOD. Attributing the whole improvement to the sensor would be exactly the error this site accuses vendors of making.

Nor is a military airfield a civil one. Yuma is a single operator flying a single fleet with one budget covering the runway, the aircraft and the engines, and with the authority to change ground procedures by order rather than by negotiation. That is the environment in which FOD programmes work, and it is precisely the environment a hub airport is not.

The figure also comes from a trade article rather than a published assessment. It should be treated as a vendor claim until NAVAIR puts numbers of its own into the public record, and if it does, that assessment will be worth more than everything else written about this technology this decade.

Five installations were planned in 2020. The obvious question — how many exist now, and whether this has become a programme of record rather than an evaluation — remains unanswered.

Source (Airports International)