FOD-Detection.com

Hitachi Kokusai’s FOD radar sees 500 metres in clear weather and 200 in heavy rain, its developers say

A paper published online on 5 April in the Turkish Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education (vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 1431–1436) gives figures for the radio-over-fibre millimetre-wave FOD radar made by Hitachi Kokusai Electric, including how far it can see in rain. Titled Review on Foreign Object Debris Detection Technologies and Advancement for Airport Safety and Surveillance, it has ten authors: three from Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, one from Universiti Malaysia Terengganu, two from Malaysia Airports, two from Japan’s National Institute of Information and Communications Technology and two from Hitachi Kokusai.

The first half is a review: visual patrols and sweeping equipment, then LiDAR rovers, cameras, radar and hybrid systems. The second half describes Hitachi Kokusai’s system, under field trial at Narita and at Kuala Lumpur International. The acknowledgements place the work in a project called the FODDS Field Trial at KLIA, funded by Japan’s Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications and a university grant.

The design generates the radar signal away from the runway and carries it over single-mode optical fibre to the radar heads, which the authors say means no runway closure to install or maintain them. The radar works at 96 GHz with 42 dB of antenna gain, alongside an HD camera with 25x zoom. The smallest object found in the KLIA trial was a 1 cm piece of asphalt, and the system is said to detect debris within 10 seconds.

The useful number is the one vendors rarely publish. Detection range is given as 500 metres in clear weather and 200 metres in rain of 20 mm an hour: a 60 per cent loss of range in a heavy downpour, with puddles adding scatter of their own. An airport that gets rain like that would space its towers on the second figure, not the first.

The comparison with other systems is weaker. A table sets the Hitachi system’s throughput of 10 seconds against 45 for FOD Finder, 70 for iFerret, 72 for Tarsier and four minutes for FODetect, and the table’s caption cites a 2010 ICAO Assembly working paper, A37-WP/191. That working paper names no systems and gives no such figures. The table also lists iFerret under Stratech, which was wound up in 2018.

The referencing is unreliable elsewhere too. In the review sections the reference numbers do not match the list, so that, as printed, the claim that automated detection can run around the clock in any weather points to a paper on finding foreign objects in milk, and the FMCW radar frequency bands to one on pavement cracking. The paper carries no competing-interests statement, although two of its authors work for the company whose system it favours and two for the airport operator hosting the trial. Its conclusion suggests that automated systems could replace the runway inspections it says ICAO requires four times a day, without citing the provision.

For airports weighing a system, the paper is worth reading for the trial figures, and the rain figure in particular. It is the developers’ account of their own radar, though, not an independent evaluation, and the comparison it draws with the four established systems rests on a source that does not contain it.

Sources (Turkish Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education, ICAO A37-WP/191)