The FOD detection market is smaller than the problem it solves
A market assessment published this week puts the airport runway FOD detection systems market at $153.79 million in 2023, forecast to reach $259.39 million by 2031, a compound annual growth rate of 6.8 per cent.
Hold that against the figure the same industry uses to sell itself. FOD is routinely costed at $4 billion a year in direct damage worldwide, and up to $22.7 billion once delays, cancellations and consequential costs are included.
So the technology sold to address a four-billion-dollar annual problem is a one-hundred-and-fifty-million-dollar annual market. Total. Worldwide. Every vendor, every airport, hardware and services combined. That is not a market failure at the margins. It is a ratio of roughly forty to one between the stated problem and the money spent on this particular answer to it, and it has been that way for fifteen years.
Three explanations, and they are not mutually exclusive.
The first is that the four-billion figure is not addressable by runway detection. Most of it is tool control, ramp discipline, line maintenance and hangar housekeeping — the torch in the F-35 engine, not the bolt on the centreline. A runway system cannot touch the majority of that cost, and quoting the total in a sales deck has always been slightly dishonest.
The second is that the cost does not land on the buyer. The airport pays for the system; the airline and the engine lessor avoid the damage. This site has been making that point since Vietnam proposed a per-flight charge in 2016 and it remains the single clearest reason the arithmetic does not close in the civil market. It closes immediately for a military operator, which is why the F-35 fleet has systems and most hub airports do not.
The third is that nobody can state the benefit. There is no published probability of detection for any fielded system, so no airport can calculate what it is buying. The FAA’s own cost-benefit analysis earlier this year had to work from detection counts — nine a month at Boston Logan — because detection counts are the only operational data that exists.
A 6.8 per cent CAGR is not a technology on the cusp of adoption. It is a technology that has found its niche and settled into it: greenfield Asian airports, military airfields, and a handful of hubs with a reason. Worth naming honestly, particularly by the people selling forecasts.
Source (GlobeNewswire)